Laparoscopic hernia repair

Last week I had a case of a 54-year-old obese woman who went to the Emergency Room with right lower quadrant/groin pain. She is a medical biller who used to work in my office. She thought she might have appendicitis, but was told that she had a right femoral hernia. She has previously undergone 3 right inguinal hernia repairs. On my examination, she had some pain in the right femoral area, but I could not demonstrate a hernia. She also said she had a left inguinal hernia, though I was not able to feel one there either.


I did a laparoscopy, and found that the tip of her appendix was adherent to a piece of marlex which must have been used as a plug in the “direct space.” I divided the adhesion, then dissected out the rest of the area. I found a wad of mesh in the femoral canal, and was unable to demonstrate what I would consider to be a hernia.

I put an 8×12 cm piece of Gore-Tex dual-mesh in to cover the entire inguinal floor. Next I explored the left side. After dissecting out the inguinal floor, I was unable to demonstrate a hernia there either. My practice in such cases has always been to proceed with the “repair” and put in a piece of PTFE… which I did in this case. I left the appendix alone, since I didn’t want to convert a clean case into a contaminated one.

What do those of you who do lap hernia repairs do when you can’t find a hernia? Do you just back out, or do a “repair”? My feeling has been that as long as I have done the dissection, there is little additional risk to putting in the PTFE (although many of you might disagree). Besides, I suppose I might weaken the floor by doing the dissection. In addition, there would be other problems such as what to tell the family, what to do if a hernia develops in the future, what to tell the lawyer who says I did unnecessary surgery… etc. It’s just easier to say there was a very very small hernia and I fixed it. I am interested in hearing how others deal with this issue.

  1. Quape
  2. Surgery
  3. Old
  4. Satva
  5. FFU
  6. tabb
  7. admin
  8. splen
  9. LN
  10. difficult
  11. don
  12. JJ17
  13. pro
  14. admin
  15. bonjo
  16. bonjo
  17. tom
  18. gren
  19. Europe
  20. supp
  21. Herky
  22. admin
  23. Satva
  24. admin
  25. 15
  26. admin
  27. cler
  28. JJ17
  29. Dr Carter

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.